CONSUMER ACQUISITION
Published: July 29, 2005
Fields of Green
 

eMarketer's Debra Aho Williamson discusses three key strategies for marketing online financial services.

Address security concerns

Security can -- and should -- be a marketing tool for online financial services.

Consumer confidence in online finance is being threatened by a steady drumbeat of news on lost, stolen or compromised data -- ever since a California law made such disclosures mandatory.

The more consumers' fears are stirred up, the greater the opportunity for a trusted financial institution to help ease those fears.

Some financial institutions are taking steps in that direction. Citibank -- one of the biggest targets of phishing attacks -- won advertising awards for a campaign that puts a humorous face on the subject of identity theft. TV spots feature dubbed voices of identity thieves talking about how they are spending their victims' money. Citibank relaunched spots from the campaign in recent months after reports that some Citibank data was lost.

One organization, TRUSTe, has begun to rally support among financial institutions for a public-service ad campaign on online fraud. Firms including Washington Mutual, MasterCard and Charles Schwab met in June 2005 to discuss ways to educate the public.

The environment appears ripe for such a campaign. Judging by the results of a Unisys survey, a significant portion of consumers would feel comforted by financial institutions that took greater responsibility for protecting their customers. (It should be noted that Unisys offers identity-fraud-detection services to financial clients.)
 


The good news for financial marketers is that younger consumers appear somewhat less concerned about security than older ones. About half of people under 35 said they are extremely concerned when using the Internet for financial transactions, according to the Conference Board and TNS NFO, vs. 60 percent of those 35-54. Still, the numbers are sizeable enough to warrant attention.

Use Search

Search marketing is a large and growing presence in the toolkit of financial marketers. It makes sense: Mortgages, insurance and investments are among the most-researched products. As a result, there has been strong interest in keyword advertising on search engines.

The search engines are doing all they can to bolster interest; Yahoo! in May 2005 publicly released a study on the role of search marketing in financial decisions, while Google has done a deep study of brokerage search habits.

Use of the internet to research financial products is growing. In a survey conducted for Yahoo! and OgilvyOne, 61 percent of online users said the internet was the primary way they researched bank accounts, and 73 percent cited the internet as a main research source for investments.
 


A separate study by Media-Screen for Google highlights that search usage is particularly high for brokerage research.
 


What this means for marketers is that consumers are going into a financial purchase decision armed with more information than ever before.

However, the brokerage business, particularly the full-service segment, is finding it challenging to assess the possibilities of search. "We've seen adoption from them, but they're trying to figure out how this is going to work and whether this is an acquisition play or a branding play for them," said Google's Jon Kaplan in an interview with eMarketer. One of the issues, according to Kaplan and others, is the need to acquire a customer with enough money to invest, and how to use search to qualify someone.

When it comes to finding search terms that work, the prescription varies by type of financial services product. In Yahoo!'s study, people who searched for credit cards were most likely to use brand terms, such as bank names. People looking for information on deposits or loans were more divided on their term usage. Specific terms, such as "high yield savings account," and general terms, such as "loan" or "banking," were commonly used.

Developing a balanced portfolio of terms will be important for financial search marketers.


Think young
 
The online financial consumer is decidedly younger than the typical financial services consumer, and that has strong implications for the ways companies need to market online.

For younger adults, who are already accustomed to going online to get information about a product or service, the idea of researching that first big financial product acquisition online is no stretch of the imagination.

Online banking, in particular, trends younger. In the Yahoo!/OgilvyOne survey, 72 percent of people under 40 prefer to use the Internet to check balances, vs. 37 percent of those over 40. And 60 percent of U.S. online users ages 28-39 use online banking, according to the Pew Internet & American Life Project.

While security concerns are rising across all age groups, younger people are the least concerned, according to the Conference Board.

The common wisdom has often been to market financial products to older generations, since they are the ones with the money. But reaching out to younger groups has a particular benefit online. These people are just starting to form financial relationships, and their choices are often guided by the research they do online.

Witness Citibank's highly successful iPod promotion, which wasn't overtly aimed at the younger demographic but certainly hit that target.

Citibank in December 2004 began offering a free iPod to consumers who opened a checking account online and paid at least two bills a month online for a year. (Bank One--now part of Chase -- launched a similar promotion in spring 2005.) A Citibank spokeswoman told American Banker in May 2005 that the bank had given away "tens of thousands" of iPods.

Said Allen Schiffenbauer, chief research officer at the Brand Consultancy, in a February 2005 article on the Citibank promotion in Bank Technology News: "The kind of people who would like an iPod are just the kind of people a bank wants as a customer. It's a good match. It's well targeted and well thought out and a very expensive campaign.... It's the demographic all banks hunger for."

Marketing messages "focused on control and empowerment" will resonate best with these younger consumers, Yahoo! and OgilvyOne recommend in their study. In addition to message, marketers need to consider the environment. A look at Nielsen//NetRatings' list of the top 10 places where financial services companies advertised online in April 2005 yields no surprises, if older adults were what these banks were after: finance sites, portals, news, weather. But if the goal is to target younger consumers, the list categories such as music, gaming and entertainment.


Debra Aho Williamson is a senior analyst at eMarketer. This article is drawn from her recent report, Financial Services: Online Marketing and Advertising.

 

White Paper Library

View More Research »